
We rank the 15 best midfielders of the AFL era (1990 to now), with honourable mentions for Joel Selwood, Andrew McLeod, James Hird, Nathan Buckley, Jimmy Bartel, Patrick Cripps and Mark Ricciuto.
Criteria: Brownlows, premierships, Norm Smiths, longevity and the simple question of who you'd want in your team on Grand Final day.
Greatest Midfielders in AFL History
The 2026 season is done and dusted and what a finish it was.
Brisbane made it three flags in a row, Nick Daicos polled a record 47 votes to win the Brownlow, and the off-season has already thrown up a few curveballs. Lachie Neale is a Magpie. Scott Pendlebury is heading to the Gold Coast.
With no footy on for a few months, it's the perfect time to settle an argument that's been running in pubs since 1990.
Who is the best midfielder of the AFL era?
The engine room is where games are won and lost. It's also where you'll find most of the game's biggest stars and unsung heroes, which made cutting this list to 15 a nightmare.
We've parked the bias as best we can. Let’s do it!
The Top 15 Best AFL Midfielders
15. Scott Pendlebury - Collingwood*
How do you rank a bloke who's played more games than anyone in the history of the game?
Pendles broke Brent Harvey's record of 432 games in Round 11 of 2026 and has amazingly signed on for another season at the Gold Coast.
He's a dual premiership player (2010 and 2023) and won the Norm Smith Medal in the 2010 Grand Final. He’s the GOAT bloke and has been one of the most durable athlete’s in Australian sports history, but Pendles hasn’t quite dominated the game as much as some others on this list.
14. Sam Mitchell - Hawthorn, West Coast
After debuting in 2002, Mitchell was the brains of the Hawks' midfield through their most successful era.
He captained Hawthorn to the 2008 flag and then played in the 2013, 2014 and 2015 three-peat, for four premierships in all.
He was awarded the 2012 Brownlow in 2016, shared with Trent Cotchin.
Silky smooth with the ball in hand, Mitchell won five Peter Crimmins Medals, was a three-time All-Australian and played 329 games, the last 22 at West Coast.
He joined the AFL Hall of Fame in 2023.
13. Marcus Bontempelli - Western Bulldogs*
The Bont has done just about everything bar win a Brownlow.
He was a key part of the Dogs drought-breaking 2016 premiership and has been captain since 2020.
He's been named All-Australian eight times, won three AFLPA MVPs (2021, 2023 and 2024) and claimed seven Charles Sutton Medals, equalling Scott West's club record.
The Brownlow keeps slipping away. He was runner-up in 2021 and 2023 and finished third this year with 34 votes. With 282 games under his belt, he's still got time.
On his day, could match it with absolutely anyone on this list, at a more successful club we could be talking about a completely different story.
12. Ben Cousins - West Coast, Richmond
Few midfielders could match Cousins for running power at his peak.
He won the 2005 Brownlow with 20 votes, edging out teammate Daniel Kerr by one, and a year later he was part of West Coast's 2006 premiership side.
He captained the Eagles from 2001 to 2005, won four club best and fairests (2001, 2002, 2003 and 2005) and was named All-Australian six times.
Cousins played 270 games, 238 of them at West Coast and the last 32 at Richmond.
Could’ve been higher if things didn’t go wrong.
11. Dane Swan - Collingwood
Swanny didn't look like your typical footballer, and he didn't play like one either. An absolute larrikin in the best way possible, we loved watching Swanny on the weekend.
He won the 2011 Brownlow with 34 votes, a 3-2-1 record at the time, a year after helping the Pies to the 2010 premiership in the Grand Final Replay.
Swan was also the 2010 AFLPA MVP, won three straight Copeland Trophies (2008-10) and was named All-Australian five years running from 2009 to 2013.
A tough competitor who stood out among some seriously high quality midfielders in the early 2010s. Swan played 258 games and entered the Hall of Fame in 2024.
10. Nat Fyfe - Fremantle Dockers
At his peak, Fyfe was close to unstoppable.
He won the Brownlow in 2015 with 31 votes and again in 2019 with 33, and was the AFLPA MVP in 2014 and 2015.
He captained the Dockers from 2017 to 2022 and was named All-Australian three times, including as skipper in 2019.
Fyfe fought injury for much of his career and retired a certified Freo legend at the end of 2025.
9. Lachie Neale - Fremantle, Brisbane Lions*
Neale arrived at Brisbane in 2019 and turned a good midfield into a great one.
He won the Brownlow in 2020 and again in 2023, polling 31 votes both times.
Then came the flags. Neale won three straight with the Lions in 2024, 2025 and 2026, two of them as co-captain.
He's played 321 games, and he'll add to that in black and white, joining Collingwood for 2027.
Lions fans might need a minute, but you’ve got to say; the man’s more than paid his dues to Brissy.
8. Patrick Dangerfield - Adelaide, Geelong*
Few midfielders have combined power and speed like Danger in full flight.
He won the 2016 Brownlow with 35 votes, a record at the time, and he's been named All-Australian eight times, including as captain in 2020.
The premiership finally came in 2022, and he's still going, with 379 games to his name after another 19 this season.
Fun fact: Danger and Gary Ablett Jr are tied for the most career Brownlow votes in history, with 262 each.
7. Robert Harvey - St Kilda
If this list were about engines alone, Harvey might top it.
The Saints champion won back-to-back Brownlows in 1997 and 1998, the first St Kilda player to go back-to-back since Ian Stewart in the 1960s.
He was named All-Australian eight times and played 383 games across 21 seasons at Moorabbin and beyond.
The only thing missing is a premiership, which is the one reason he isn't higher. He's in the Australian Football Hall of Fame and is a St Kilda Legend.
6. Simon Black - Brisbane Lions
The quiet achiever in the best midfield of the modern era.
Black never looked rushed, which is a handy trait when three blokes are trying to tackle you.
He won the 2002 Brownlow with 25 votes and played in all three of Brisbane's premierships from 2001 to 2003.
His finest hour came in the 2003 Grand Final, when he racked up 39 disposals and took home the Norm Smith Medal.
By the time he hung up the boots in 2013, he'd played 322 games, a Lions club record at the time.
5. Chris Judd - West Coast, Carlton Blues
Judd won Brownlows at two different clubs: 2004 with West Coast and 2010 with Carlton, polling 30 votes both times.
In between, he captained the Eagles to the 2006 flag.
The year before, he won the Norm Smith Medal in a losing Grand Final. In fact, no one did it again until Shai Bolton this year.
Explosive out of stoppages and impossible to tag, Judd played 279 games and went into the Hall of Fame in his first year of eligibility.
4. Michael Voss - Brisbane Bears, Brisbane Lions
Before Neale's three-peat, there was Voss's.
The Lions skipper led Brisbane to premierships in 2001, 2002 and 2003, captaining the club in all three.
He shared the 1996 Brownlow with James Hird and remains the only Brisbane Bears player to win the game's highest individual honour.
Voss played 289 games and was the heartbeat of a side that's still in the conversation for the greatest of the AFL era.
3. Adam Goodes - Sydney, Swans
Goodes started as a ruckman, finished as a forward and spent his best years dominating through the middle.
He shared the 2003 Brownlow with Mark Ricciuto and Nathan Buckley on 22 votes, then won it outright in 2006.
He played in Sydney's 2005 and 2012 premierships, was named All-Australian four times and won three Bob Skilton Medals.
An absolute icon and credit to the game, Goodes won the Rising Star in 1999, co-captained the Swans from 2009 to 2012 and finished with 372 games and 464 goals.
A freak of a player and an even better bloke, Goodesy transcended the sport when he was named Australian of the Year in 2014.
2. Dustin Martin - Richmond
Don't argue.
In 2017, Dusty became the first player in VFL/AFL history to win the Brownlow, the Norm Smith and a premiership in the same season.
His 36 votes that year were a record at the time, and his 11-vote winning margin is still the joint record, equalled by Daicos this year.
An out-and-out athlete and an example of the modern Aussie Rules Football player, Dusty was an absolute pleasure to watch throughout his career at the Tiges.
Martin won further flags in 2019 and 2020, and the Norm Smith in both, making him the only three-time Norm Smith medallist in history.
When the stakes were highest, nobody was better.
One of the best to ever do it, Dusty retired in 2024 after 302 games.
1. Gary Ablett Jr - Geelong, Gold Coast
Was there ever any doubt?
The Little Master won two Brownlows at two clubs: 2009 with Geelong and 2013 with Gold Coast.
He won premierships with the Cats in 2007 and 2009 and was named All-Australian eight years in a row from 2007 to 2014.
He also won the AFL Players' Association MVP five times, more than anyone in history.
Ablett finished with 357 games and went into the Hall of Fame this year, unanimously, in his first year of eligibility.
The best midfielder of the AFL era, and it isn't especially close.
*Odds are subject to change.




